A website analytics checklist is a short, repeatable list of checks you run every quarter to catch problems before they cost you traffic or leads. Done well, it covers four things, broken links, AI search visibility, ranking changes, and conversion tracking. None of it needs a developer or a dedicated specialist, just about an hour and two free tools.
Nobody joins a marketing team dreaming about bounce rates and conversion reports. Most marketing managers running a website solo already have twenty things pulling at their day, and a proper website analytics checklist is the first thing that gets bumped. It slides to next week. Then next month. Then a year's gone by and nobody's looked.
This guide walks through each of the four checks in real detail, not just what to look for, but exactly where to click and what a problem actually looks like once you find it.
The four checks at a glance
- Broken links, are dead pages or links hurting your rankings and user experience.
- AI search visibility, are you being cited in AI Overviews, ChatGPT and Perplexity.
- Ranking changes, have your key pages moved up or down over the last quarter.
- Conversion tracking, are your key actions still recording correctly.
Why Does Website Analytics Keep Slipping Down the Priority List?
Website analytics keeps slipping because nobody officially owns it. In most small marketing teams, one person is running the website, the socials, the newsletter, and half the events calendar, and analytics is the task with no deadline attached, so it's the one that moves.
It's not a knowledge problem. Most marketing managers know what a bounce rate is and could read a report if they sat down with one. The real issue is time and ownership. Nobody calls a meeting about conversion tracking that quietly broke three months ago, so it never feels urgent until the quarter's numbers look strange and nobody can say why.
Picture a fairly typical scenario. A marketing manager updates the website's contact form provider in March, tests it once, and moves on to the next project. The old tracking code was never reconnected to the new form. Nobody notices, because the form still visually works, visitors can still submit it, and the emails still land in the inbox. But because the tracking broke, every "leads generated" number reported to the board for the rest of the year is wrong, understating real performance and making the marketing team's actual results look worse than they are.
Add a website platform that buries reporting behind an IT request, and it's easy to see why quarterly checks turn into yearly ones, or stop happening at all. A digital experience platform that keeps your website, forms and reporting under one roof removes a lot of that friction, since nobody has to wait on IT just to see how the site is performing.
What Should Be on a Quarterly Website Analytics Checklist?
A quarterly website analytics checklist should cover four things, broken links, AI search visibility, ranking changes, and conversion tracking.
Below is an estimate of time needed, but it is dependent on how in-depth you want to go and what tools (and automations you set up).
These four made the cut because they're the ones most likely to break quietly, with nobody noticing until there's a real cost attached, lost traffic, lost visibility, or lost leads. None of them need a specialist or a paid tool, and none of them need code changes to check, only to fix.
Block an hour once a quarter, work through the four checks below in order, and you'll catch most problems before they've had time to do real damage.
| Check |
What to look at |
Tool |
Time needed |
| Broken links |
404 errors and dead internal links |
Google Search Console, Screaming Frog or Ahrefs Webmaster Tools |
15 to 20 minutes |
| AI search visibility |
Whether you're cited in AI answers, schema validity, robots.txt |
Google AI Mode, ChatGPT, Perplexity, Rich Results Test |
15 to 20 minutes |
| Ranking changes |
Position and click changes over 90 days |
Google Search Console |
10 to 15 minutes |
| Conversion tracking |
Whether key actions still fire correctly |
GA4 Realtime report |
10 to 15 minutes |
Check 1: Are Broken Links Hurting Your Rankings and User Experience?
Broken links hurt you two ways at once. They frustrate visitors who hit a dead end, and they tell search engines your site isn't well maintained. Both push people, and your rankings, in the wrong direction.
How to check for and fix broken links
- Open Google Search Console, go to the Pages report under Indexing, then scroll to "Why pages aren't indexed" and look for "Not found (404)". This shows every URL Google has tried to crawl and failed to find.

- Run a free crawl of your own site with Screaming Frog's SEO Spider (free for up to 500 URLs) or Ahrefs Webmaster Tools (free once you verify ownership), to catch broken internal links Google hasn't found yet.
- Cross reference your list against your top landing pages in GA4 (Reports, then Engagement, then Pages and screens), and fix anything with the highest traffic first.

- For each broken link, either restore the missing page or set up a redirect, a permanent sign telling Google and visitors the content has moved. Most modern content management systems let a content editor do this without a developer.

One habit worth avoiding: fixing links one at a time as you stumble across them during the year. That's how a list of forty becomes normal instead of alarming. Running this check on a schedule, rather than reactively, is what keeps the number low.
Tip: You can ask your AI tool to check broken URLs on your behalf in Google Search Console and check it against your top landing pages in GA4 to create a priority list. Then ask it to either create a reusable prompt or schedule it to run the process every quarter.

Check 2: Are You Still Showing Up in AI Search Answers?
AI search visibility means checking whether your business actually shows up when someone asks an AI tool a question your customers would ask. It matters as much as your Google ranking now, and almost nobody is checking it yet.
How to check your AI search visibility
- Build a list of five to eight real customer questions, pulled from Search Console's Performance report (filter to queries starting with "how," "what," "why" or "best" that have high impressions but low clicks) plus sales emails, live chat and support tickets. If you want it to surface queries with all these keywords, use regex '^(how|what|why|best)\b'

- Search each question on Google and note whether an AI Overview appears, whether you're cited, which page is cited, and which competitors show up instead.
- Run the same questions through Google's AI Mode tab, then ChatGPT and Perplexity, and log every result in a simple spreadsheet so you can track movement each quarter.
- Run your key pages through Google's free Rich Results Test at search.google.com/test/rich-results to confirm your FAQ and article schema still validates.
- Check your robots.txt file (yoursite.com.au/robots.txt) to make sure it isn't blocking AI crawlers like GPTBot, OAI-SearchBot, ClaudeBot, PerplexityBot or Google-Extended.
- Check AI referral traffic in GA4 (Reports, then Acquisition, then Traffic acquisition) for the channel called 'AI Assistant' or sources like chatgpt.com, perplexity.ai or gemini.google.com.

AI Overviews and AI Mode have only been common in Australian search results for a short time, so very few competitors have gotten around to checking this yet, which makes it one of the easier wins on this whole list.
Here's a useful extra step for this check. Most marketing managers reach for ChatGPT or Claude for general help but never ask it to actually audit their AEO position. A well built prompt, with real detail about your business dropped in, will do far more than a generic "how do I rank in AI answers" question ever will.
Try this prompt in Claude or ChatGPT, filling in your own details in the brackets:
"I run [type of business] in Australia. Our main products or services are [list them]. Our ideal customer is [describe their role, the size of organisation they work in, and the problem they're trying to solve]. Here are the actual questions our customers and prospects ask us before they buy, taken from real emails and chats: [paste 8 to 10 real questions].
Our main competitors are [list 3 to 5 names]. What we genuinely do differently is [your specific, honest differentiators, not generic marketing lines].
Here is the content on our website meant to answer these kinds of questions: [paste the URLs, or paste the actual text of your top 5 to 10 pages].
Acting as an AI search optimisation reviewer, for each question I listed tell me whether our existing content answers it directly within the first sentence or two, which of our pages does the best job, what's missing that a more complete competitor resource would likely include, and a suggested new FAQ question with a genuinely useful 40 to 60 word answer we could add.
Also flag any of our headings that read as marketing statements rather than questions a customer would actually type or ask an AI assistant, and suggest a better, question based alternative for each one.
Finish by telling me which three content gaps you'd fix first, based on how often these questions likely come up and how weak our current coverage is."
The context that makes this work is the real detail you paste in, actual customer questions in their own words, your genuine competitors, and your genuine differentiators. A vague prompt gets vague, generic advice back. A specific one gets you a prioritised, business relevant action list.
Check 3: Have Your Search Rankings Moved?
Checking your rankings means comparing where your key pages sit in Google's results now against where they sat last quarter. A drop of a position or two is normal. A page falling off the first page entirely is worth investigating.
How to check your rankings
- Open Search Console's Performance report and use the date comparison picker (top left, next to the date range) to compare the last 90 days against the 90 days before that.

- Switch to the Pages tab, sort by clicks, and focus on your top 10 to 20 pages, then check the Queries tab the same way for your most important keywords.

- Compare the same quarter against last year too, not just last quarter, since seasonal swings can look like a problem when they aren't.
- If a page has genuinely slipped, average position sliding from around 4 to somewhere past 15, or clicks nearly halving while impressions stay flat, search the keyword yourself, see what's now ranking above it, and refresh your page with more current, more complete content.
Keep a simple record of what you find each quarter too. A single spreadsheet row per quarter, noting which pages moved and why, turns four isolated checks into a genuine trend line you can show in a board report.
Tip: Use your AI tool to perform this task on your behalf!
Check 4: Are Your Key Conversions Still Tracking Correctly?
Your key conversions may not be tracking correctly if a recent site update, a new cookie consent banner, or a plugin change has broken a tracking event without triggering any kind of alert, since nothing tells you when this happens. This is the check most teams skip, and it's the one that costs the most, because your reports keep looking normal while the numbers underneath are wrong.
Cookie consent banners are a particularly common culprit, since many are set up to block your analytics tag entirely until a visitor actively accepts cookies, which means anyone who ignores or dismisses the banner is invisible to your reporting from that point on. It's worth checking your consent setup lines up with the Privacy Act 1988 and the Australian Privacy Principles while you're in there, since consent and tracking rules go hand in hand.
How to check your conversion tracking
- Open GA4's Realtime report (Reports, then Realtime) in one browser tab, and your live website in another.
- Go through each conversion action yourself, submit the contact form, download the resource, click through to request a demo, and watch whether the matching event appears in Realtime within a minute or two.
- Repeat once in a normal browser window, and again in a private or incognito window where you actively decline cookies, so you can see both the accepted and declined paths.
- Compare your GA4 lead count for the quarter against the actual number of enquiries sitting in your inbox or CRM for the same period. If GA4 says twelve and your inbox says twenty, tracking has broken somewhere in between.
If you're on the Elcom platform, the Data Insights Dashboard shows form submissions and key engagement activity in one place, which makes this sanity check faster since you're not jumping between a separate analytics tool and a separate form provider to compare numbers. You can see how it works in a live demo if that's useful.
What Actually Happens If You Skip This?
Skipping this checklist doesn't cause one obvious disaster. It causes a slow build up of decisions made on bad data, and by the time anyone notices, months have usually gone by.
Broken conversion tracking is the worst offender. If a form quietly stops recording submissions and nobody catches it for a quarter, every report and every budget conversation in that window rests on a number that's simply wrong. Nobody sets out to make decisions on bad data. It just happens, one missed check at a time, and it's often only caught by accident, when someone happens to compare a report against their inbox and the numbers don't line up. Hidden source fields give you a backup record of where each lead came from, and they're one of the quick fixes for website forms worth doing this quarter.
When an AI Overview appears on a Google results page, people click through to a normal search result in just 8% of visits, down from 15% when no AI summary appears. (Pew Research Center, 2025)
If your business has gone quiet in those AI answers and nobody's looked, that's a growing share of your audience going elsewhere before they ever reach your website. None of this needs to happen. It's the result of a checklist nobody scheduled, not a lack of care. It's also a good time to check how much of your audience you own.
The damage compounds too. A ranking drop caught in month one is usually a quick content refresh. The same drop left for a year often means rebuilding a page from scratch, or losing the keyword to a competitor for good.
How Can You Make This Checklist Easier to Stick To?
The easiest way to make sure this actually happens each quarter is to remove every decision from the process except doing it. Put it on a recurring calendar block, use the same simple template every time, and make sure whoever's responsible can reach the data without filing a ticket first.
Set a reminder for the first week of each quarter, and keep a one page template, a shared document with the four checks already listed and space to note what you found, so there's nothing left to plan, just fill it in. A shared Google Doc or a page in whatever project tool your team already uses works fine, the tool matters less than making sure it's somewhere the whole team can find without asking you first. If you're the only person who ever runs it, name a backup too. A checklist that lives entirely in one person's head disappears the moment that person is busy, on leave, or moves on.
The other lever worth pulling is your platform.
Better yet, automate as much of it as possible using your chosen AI tool. For example, you can create 'Scheduled' aka recurring tasks in Claude and ChatGPT to run. Simply prompt it with what it should do or produce. Then when you're happy ask it to schedule it as a quarterly task.

Conclusion
A website analytics checklist run every quarter, covering broken links, AI search visibility, ranking changes, and conversion tracking, catches most of the problems that quietly cost a business traffic and leads long before they show up in a board report.
None of it requires a developer, an agency, or someone with "analytics" in their job title. It needs an hour, two free tools, and a calendar reminder that actually gets kept. The teams that stay on top of this aren't the ones with more resources, they're the ones who've made it a habit instead of a project.
If any of these four checks turned up something more involved than a quick fix, a good next step is a consultation with our team, or take a look at how an all in one website and CMS platform can make these checks part of your everyday reporting instead of a quarterly scramble.